Debate - Judging Schedule Philosophy 103

Guidelines for Debaters

Guidelines for Judges

 

 

 

Debate 1: 2.12

 

Is there anything new in the moral issues raised by computers?

Debaters:

Judge both debaters of assigned side

Yes:

 

 

Anderson, Mathew

Arciga, Samantha Peralta

Yes:

 

 

Atwal, Gurraj S Bajramovic, Dino

No:

 

 

Ball, Eric Baptista, Daniel F

No:

 

 

Bennett, Kyle Alexander Caraang, Melvin James

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Debate 2: 2.19

 

Is the sole responsibility of business to increase profits?

Debaters:

Judge both debaters of assigned side

Yes:

Chang, Van Meng

 

Chen, Dan

Yes:

Burkhart, Nathan

Capili Jr, Michael

No:

Cruit, John Michael

 

Doucette, Justin A

No:

De Arco, David

 

Dyer, Bradley

Debate 3: 2.24

 

 


 

Can business be moral and make a profit?

Debaters:

Judge both debaters of assigned side

Yes:

 

Duby, Brian Edward

 

 

Eddy, Sean Christopher

 

Yes:

Eillis, John W.

 

Fountain, Jeriel I.

 

 

 

No:

 

Ellis, David J.

 

Escropiso Jr., Ronaldo

 

No:

Green, Daniel J

 

Han, Beomjin

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

Debate 4: 3.3

 

Should employers be morally required to give reasons for firing decisions?

Debaters:

Judge both debaters of assigned side

Yes:

Fairchad, Kevin T.

Garrido, Javier

Yes:

He, Candy Gar W. Huynh, Lap D

No:

Garciano, Lucas Anthony

 

Haith Jr., George J.

No:

Kramer, Catherine A

 

Leyto, Quincy Calivara

 


 

 

Debate 5: 3.12

Is computer compiling of data on citizens socially beneficial?

Debaters:

Judge both debaters of assigned side

Yes:

 

Hill, John J.

 

Kondrashov, Maksim

 

Yes:

Luong, Johnson

 

Mandeville, Robert Chase

 

 

 

No:

McBayer, Shawn Edison

 

Mirecki, Jenna Paige Kayla

 

 

 

No:

Maokhamphiou, Ratsamy S.

 

McNeill, Damon J.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Debate 6: 3.19

 

Are all lies immoral?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

 

Pastor, Gabriel Alonso Peterson

 

Joseph Miles Pokrajac, Lucas

 

Yes & No:

 

 

Morales, Edgar

 

Parnia, Arash

No:

 

Anderson Rerucha, Jeff Russel

 


 

Debate 7: 4.9

Should we limit free speech for on-line communication?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

Rico, Robert Martinez

 

Sanchez, Andres

 

 

 

 

Yes & No:

 

 

Patel, Hinesh Praful

 

Sachao, David K.

No:

Sanchez, Jennifer Illiana

Santonil, Anthony Encarnacion

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Debate 8: 4.14

 

Does each person deserve his/her qualifications?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

Solano, Christian

 

 

 

Yes & No:

 

 

Shankar, Puja S.

Sherman, Brandon D.

No:

 

Tariq, Suffyan

 


 

Debate 9: 4.23

Is whistle blowing morally required?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

Thao, Lee C

 

 

 

 

Yes & No:

 

 

Sun, Xiaoran

 

Tesema, Natnael H.

No:

 

 

 

Tran Nguyen, Hoang Minh

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Debate 10: 4.30

 

Ought legality to be the only limit on acceptable advertising?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

Tuazon Jr, Rommel Panopio

 

 

 

Yes & No:

 

 

Thach, Charlie N.

Tran, Hai

No:

 

Vogt, Austin J

 


 

Debate 11: 5.5

Ought private goods to rank higher in value than public goods?

Debaters:

Judges

Yes:

 

 

Vongsavanh, Lathsamy

Yes & No:

 

 

Wilcox, Joshua Kevin Wong, Matthew

Zander, Jacob Delbert

No:

 

West, Cynthis Lee