CSU Sacramento Advisory Standards for Writing

The following rubric was created by the Faculty Senate Subcommittee for Writing and Reading. It is meant as a useful guide but not an absolute standard for the university: writing criteria will vary from instructor to instructor and discipline to discipline.  

An “A” paper:  A paper in this category

• Addresses the assignment thoughtfully and analytically, setting a challenging task.

• Does not demonstrate a need for more revision.

• Displays awareness of and purpose in communicating to an audience.

• Establishes a clearly focused controlling idea.

• Demonstrates coherent and rhetorically sophisticated organization; makes
  effective connections between ideas.

• Provides clear generalizations with specific detail and compelling support and analysis.

• Cites relevant sources and evaluates their validity, effectively integrating them into the text when appropriate.

• Displays evidence of careful editing with superior control of grammar and mechanics appropriate to the assignment.

Guideline for multilingual writers: Grammatical errors are rare and do not interfere with overall effectiveness of paper; occasional imprecision in word choice and usage may occur. 

A “B” paper: A paper in this category

• Addresses the assignment clearly and analytically, setting a meaningful task.

• Does not demonstrate a need for significantly more revision.

• Addresses audience needs and expectations.

• Establishes a clearly focused controlling idea.

• Demonstrates clear and coherent organization.

• Provides clear generalizations and effective support and analysis.

• Cites relevant sources, effectively integrating them into the text when appropriate.

• Displays evidence of careful editing with consistent control of grammar and mechanics appropriate to the assignment and the discipline.

Guideline for multilingual writers: Some grammatical errors may occur throughout the paper but do not interfere with overall effectiveness; occasional inappropriate word choice or incorrect usage may occur. 

A “C” paper: A paper in this category

• Addresses the assignment with some analysis.

• Demonstrates some need for further revision. 

• Addresses most audience needs and expectations.

• Establishes a controlling idea.

• Demonstrates adequate organization.

• Provides support for and some analysis of generalizations.

• Cites appropriate sources, adequately integrating them into text.

• Displays evidence of editing with adequate control of grammar and mechanics appropriate to the assignment. Errors do not slow the reader, impede understanding, or seriously undermine the authority of the writer.

Guideline for multilingual writers: Grammatical errors, inappropriate word choice, or incorrect usage may occur throughout the paper but rarely interfere with effective communication. 

A “D” paper has some of the following qualities: A paper in this category

• Does not address the assignment adequately.

• Demonstrates a need for significantly more revision.

• Does not show sufficient audience awareness.

• Strays from the controlling idea, or the idea is unclear.

• Displays random or confusing organization.

• Lacks generalizations, or gives generalizations but does not provide support or analysis.

• Does not cite sources or does not cite and/or integrate sources appropriately.

• Needs significant editing for grammar and mechanics; errors impede understanding.

Guideline for multilingual writers: Serious and frequent errors in grammar, word choice, or usage seriously hinder communication.

 An “F” paper has many or all of the qualities listed under a “D” paper.

 
Guidelines for Evaluating the Writing of Multilingual Writers: The writing of multilingual students should be held to native speaker standards for content and addressing the assignment.  However, because certain types of errors persist in multilingual writing even at an advanced level, some accommodation for multilingual features is appropriate.