Method

Unit of Analysis

Key Concepts

View of Audience

Major Theorists

Key Assumptions

Ideological Criticism

Social forces, economic relationships

Hegemony,

Determinism, legitimation

Dupes and pawns

Marx, Gramsci, Althusser

False consciousness is supported by the media.  The media offer an arena for contested ideology.

Gender Criticism

Roles, relationships,

Positioning,

Patriarchy,

Feminism

 

Susceptible to influence

Modleski, Vande Berg,

Dow

Television is an extension of a culture that socializes men and women into preconceived roles.

Textual Criticism

Signs, codes, and signifiers

Semiotics, synchronic and diachronic

Active readers of text

Propp, Berger, Fisk and Hartley

Television programs are complex texts with overlapping and often contradictory layers of meaning.

Audience-Centered Criticism

Actual audience member responses

Focus groups, active audience, uses and grats

Empowered choice makers

Radway, Ang, Jenkins, Fish

Television means what an audience says it means; the approach privileges the audience not the critic.

Auteur Criticism

The creative force behind the show

Mis en scene, thematic motifs

 

Appreciative of artistic choices

Davis, Feuer, Thompson

Television programming can be read as the output of a particular creative genius (or team)

Cultural Criticism

Roles and norms, socialization forces

Critique, liberation

At the mercy of various forces

Hall, Fiske, British Cultural Studies

TV is one of many powerful forces affecting society.  One must keep a clear perspective on its influence.

Institutional Criticism

Power roles, economic relationships

Imperialism,

Political economy, tensions

Unaware of all but the obvious programs

Turow, Bagdikian, Barnouw

Television is the quintessential result of institutional artistic effort.  Understanding this unlocks significant insights for the critic.