Method |
Unit of Analysis |
Key Concepts |
View of Audience |
Major Theorists |
Key Assumptions |
Ideological Criticism |
Social forces, economic relationships |
Hegemony, Determinism, legitimation |
Dupes and pawns |
Marx, Gramsci, Althusser |
False consciousness is supported by the media. The media offer an arena for contested ideology. |
Gender Criticism |
Roles, relationships, |
Positioning, Patriarchy, Feminism |
Susceptible to influence |
Modleski, Vande Berg, Dow |
Television is an extension of a culture that socializes men and women into preconceived roles. |
Textual Criticism |
Signs, codes, and signifiers |
Semiotics, synchronic and diachronic |
Active readers of text |
Propp, Berger, Fisk and Hartley |
Television programs are complex texts with overlapping and often contradictory layers of meaning. |
Audience-Centered Criticism |
Actual audience member responses |
Focus groups, active audience, uses and grats |
Empowered choice makers |
Radway, Ang, Jenkins, Fish |
Television means what an audience says it means; the approach privileges the audience not the critic. |
Auteur Criticism |
The creative force behind the show |
Mis en scene, thematic motifs |
Appreciative of artistic choices |
Davis, Feuer, Thompson |
Television programming can be read as the output of a particular creative genius (or team) |
Cultural Criticism |
Roles and norms, socialization forces |
Critique, liberation |
At the mercy of various forces |
Hall, Fiske, British Cultural Studies |
TV is one of many powerful forces affecting society. One must keep a clear perspective on its
influence. |
Institutional Criticism |
Power roles, economic relationships |
Imperialism, Political economy, tensions |
Unaware of all but the obvious programs |
Turow, Bagdikian, Barnouw |
Television is the quintessential result of institutional artistic effort. Understanding this unlocks significant insights for the critic. |