Student Name___________________________________________________________

Date of  Argumentation __________(do not omit!)Group # Presenting___________

Instructions: Top row, write the last name, initial of the speaker to be evaluated.
Each row across is for entering the traditional evaluative grade for the speaker named at the top, A thru F, based on the criteria given to the left of the row.

Last name, initial--->








Speaker gave a clear argument , targeted his/her remarks at specific premises and could identify the S,M and P.








Speaker’s argument was a good philosophic point and on the topic assigned.








Speaker attacked or defended his/her chosen premise well. Any essential premise not given much attention was easily seen to be true or false.








Speaker was able to answer obvious objections and was well prepared.








Speaker did well with difficult objections and had thought issues thru and had read the author well.